Semtum

Would owning less have beaten your strategy?

Compare your strategy against simply holding a smaller fraction of the market at the same drawdown. Most risk-management features fail this. Free calculator.

Tool 4 of 5

If your strategy's selling point is that it loses less in a crash, this is the one comparison that decides whether it is worth running.

Watch: what goes in
What it tells you

There is a trivially simple way to cut your worst loss: own less of the thing. Put 60% in the market and 40% in cash and your worst fall drops by roughly 40%, with no signals, no indicators, no code and no screen time. So the real test for any risk-management feature is whether it beats that, at the same worst fall. Most do not. Covered calls and trailing stops both fail this test; trend filters pass it.

Load the market’s daily prices below and the yardstick numbers fill themselves in; you only need your own two.

Peak to trough. Tool 2 computes it.

The market you would otherwise just have held. Load a file of its daily prices and its yearly rate and worst fall are worked out for you, or choose Custom and type them. The practice markets are made-up prices, for learning the tool, not a real yardstick.

A rough scaling: holding a fraction f of the book gives roughly f times the drawdown and f times the arithmetic return, less compounding drag. Good enough to settle the question; use the Python harness on real position data for a number you would act on. The practice figures come from made-up prices and only show how the tool works. For a real comparison, load the market’s own prices over the window you tested on, or score it in tool 2 and type those figures here.

Where this number comes from

The free first module works through the arithmetic behind this calculator: where the bar comes from, why looking twice raises it, and what to do when your result sits below it. Subscribe for one email every two weeks about what I tested.

Your address is used for this and nothing else. Every email has a one-click unsubscribe.

If a tool here told you something uncomfortable

Why your backtest lied to you

The free first module explains the arithmetic behind these calculators in full: where the bar comes from, why looking twice raises it, and what to do when your result sits below it. No signup, ~14 minutes.

Read it free

The full course is eight modules, nineteen data sources with the trap in each, twelve working download scripts and the searchable ledger of every approach I tested, one of which survived. See what is in it →

These match the Python toolkit. The noise-floor integration is the same calculation as the toolkit’s own noise floor; the real-money bar here uses the exact closed form where the Python simulates it, so it may differ in the second decimal. Everything runs in your browser; nothing you paste is sent anywhere, and the page works with no internet connection.

This is not financial advice and not a recommendation to buy or sell anything. A result that clears every bar on this page is a reason to collect forward data, not a reason to fund it. See Module 8.